I had planned the perfect birthday celebration for my husband, Ethan—bright sunshine, great music, amazing food, and all the people he loved. Everything was going smoothly… until my sister-in-law, Maddie, showed up with an unexpected guest: Ethan’s ex-girlfriend, Chloe.
I’m Kate, and Ethan and I have been married for five years. We’ve built a life full of love, laughter, and shared quirks. But the one ongoing challenge in our story has always been Maddie. From the beginning, she’s been incredibly close to Chloe and never quite warmed up to me.
The morning of the party, while I was handling last-minute details, Maddie called to ask about spicy hummus—something Ethan loves. I assured her I had it covered. Then she casually mentioned bringing a few extra guests. I didn’t ask who, assuming it was harmless. Looking back, I should’ve asked.
When Maddie arrived, Chloe was right beside her—wearing a bold red dress and high heels that were far from patio-friendly. She greeted Ethan with a warm “Happy Birthday!” and quickly dove into old memories, barely acknowledging me.
I pulled Maddie aside and asked why Chloe was there.
“She’s like family,” Maddie said innocently.
“She’s your brother’s ex,” I reminded her.
Continue reading on next page…