In the early hours of December 16, 2009, Giuseppe “Joe” Martinelli arrived at his bakery on Bleecker Street, following the same routine he had kept for more than twenty years. At sixty-three, habit defined his mornings: unlock the door, switch on the lights, start the ovens. But that day, something was different.
In the storage room, he noticed a section of floorboards near the wall had begun to bulge. Curious, he pried them open and discovered a hidden cavity lined with concrete. Inside was a metal box wrapped carefully in plastic.
The box contained a faded red lunchbox, rusted but still sealed. When Joe opened it, documents spilled across his counter—birth certificates, Social Security cards, and identification papers, all bearing the name Rodriguez. Alongside them were family photographs of two children and their smiling parents. At the bottom lay an old newspaper clipping: “Family of Four Vanishes on Christmas Eve. Police Baffled.” The date was December 26, 1995.
The missing family was David and Carmen Rodriguez, along with their children Sophia, eight, and Alex, six. They had been last seen on Christmas Eve, reportedly leaving their home with luggage, their holiday dinner still left unfinished. For fourteen years, their disappearance had remained a mystery.
Continue reading on the next page…