At the time of the sinking, the National Weather Service reported 27 mph winds, four-foot waves, 12-degree air temperatures, and water temperatures around 39 degrees—conditions that left even experienced mariners at serious risk.
Final Hours
Hours before the tragedy, Capt. Sebastian Noto, a friend and fellow fisherman, spoke with Sanfilippo around 3 a.m. He recalls Gus remarking, “I quit. It’s too cold,” yet his tone was calm, a reflection of his years at sea. Noto suspects a possible bilge pump malfunction, noting that even with water entering the vessel, the crew would normally have had time to deploy life rafts and signal for help.
Remembering the Crew
The six others aboard included crew members Paul Beal Sr., Paul Beal, John Rousanidis, Freeman Short, Sean Therrien, and NOAA fisheries observer Jada Samitt. “The decision to suspend the search was incredibly difficult,” said Capt. Jamie Frederick, Commander of Coast Guard Sector Boston. “Our thoughts and prayers are with all the family members and friends of the lost crew of the Lily Jean, and with the entire Gloucester community during this heartbreaking time.”
Vito Giacalone, head of the Gloucester Fishing Community Preservation Fund, described the tragedy as a blow to a tight-knit brotherhood. “We loved each other. Gus treated me like a big brother, and I treated him like my younger brother,” he said. “To know the kind of character Gus had, he’d be mortified that these lives were lost.”
Life Ashore and Legacy
Sanfilippo, son of a Sicilian fisherman, grew up on Gloucester’s docks, spending summers aboard his father’s boat before marrying his high school sweetheart, Lorie. He eventually bought his own vessel, captaining it with pride and mentoring young fishermen along the way. Beyond the sea, he was a skilled carpenter, building his family’s home with his own hands.
During his funeral on February 10, attended by family, friends, and Governor Maura Healey, Sanfilippo was remembered not only for his bravery and skill at sea but also for his generosity, humor, and dedication to the community. Gloucester Mayor Paul Lundberg announced that the names of all those lost aboard the Lily Jean will be added to the city’s memorial honoring fishermen lost at sea.
A Community Mourns
The loss of Gus Sanfilippo and his crew is a stark reminder of the dangers faced by those who work at sea. The Gloucester community, along with loved ones across New England, continues to grieve, honoring the courage and legacy of these men who gave their lives in pursuit of their calling.
Share your thoughts or memories of Capt. Gus Sanfilippo and the Lily Jean crew in the comments below. Their courage deserves to be remembered.