In October 2024, both animals were removed from the couple’s home by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) and later euthanized. According to the DEC and local health authorities, the action was taken after reports of the illegal keeping of wildlife and concerns over potential rabies exposure. Officials stated that Peanut had bitten an agent during the operation, prompting testing. Both animals later tested negative for rabies.
Longo expressed deep sadness over the loss in a public statement, describing Peanut as his best friend and a central part of his life for many years. The couple’s lawsuit alleges that the animals’ deaths were unnecessary and caused significant emotional and financial harm, including lost income from social media appearances and related content.
The legal complaint names the State of New York, the DEC, and the Department of Health as defendants, claiming the removal and euthanasia of Peanut and Fred was excessive and avoidable. In addition to this filing, the couple has initiated a separate lawsuit against local and state entities and individuals, seeking further damages through a jury trial.
Attorney Nora Constance Marino, representing Longo and Bittner, said their aim is to secure justice for her clients and to bring attention to the treatment of animals in similar situations. She expressed hope that the case will help prevent future incidents.
The couple continues to share that the loss of Peanut and Fred has left them heartbroken, and they hope the lawsuits will lead to greater protections for animals and pet owners in the future.