Judge Deadra Jefferson sentenced Jamie to 25 years in prison after she pleaded guilty to multiple charges, including felony DUI, reckless homicide, and DUI causing great bodily injury or death. The sentences will run concurrently, with Jamie serving a total of 25 years. During her trial, Jamie admitted her guilt and took responsibility for the accident.
In a statement following the sentencing, Aric expressed that the punishment matched the crime, acknowledging Jamie’s remorse but emphasizing that it could not undo the loss of his wife. “It doesn’t change the fact that Sam’s not here,” he said, sharing the pain of losing her hours after promising to protect her.
Before the sentencing, family members addressed the court. Benjamin Garrett spoke about the guilt he felt, saying, “It was my only job and I didn’t get to complete it. We didn’t get hit, we got ran through. All four of us should have died that night. I believe Sam saved us.”
In a tearful moment, Aric shared his grief over losing Samantha so soon after their wedding, recalling their final moments together. “She told me she didn’t want the night to end. I kissed her on the forehead, and then the next thing I remember is waking up in the hospital.”
Samantha’s family created a GoFundMe to cover the costs of her burial and medical expenses for Aric and the others. Annette Hutchinson, Aric’s mother, shared the devastating details of the crash, noting that Aric had undergone multiple surgeries and faced a long recovery, while Benjamin and Brogan also suffered significant injuries.
Annette also reflected on the loss of her daughter-in-law, stating, “I was handed Aric’s wedding ring in a plastic bag at the hospital, five hours after Sam placed it on his finger.” The family appreciated the support from donors and shared updates on the ongoing recovery.
Samantha’s memory was celebrated by loved ones, including Mandi Jenkins, who launched a GoFundMe campaign in her honor. Mandi described Samantha as a “pure love” who made everyone around her smile with her heart. “She was fearless and spent the last day of her life full of love and excitement,” she wrote.
Family members, including Brittany Clawson Hutchinson, shared emotional tributes on social media, remembering Samantha’s joyful spirit through photos and videos from her life, wedding, and moments shared with family.
We extend our deepest condolences to Aric, Samantha’s family, and all who loved her. May they find healing as they cope with this tragic loss. Rest in peace, Samantha.