Daniel believed his life was perfect—he had a loving wife, a newborn daughter, and was preparing to celebrate Brittany’s baptism. But when the priest took their baby into his arms, Daniel’s joy vanished. “This is impossible,” he whispered, sending a chill through the church. In that moment, his world began to crumble.
I stood by the nursery window, watching the soft morning light filter through the curtains, illuminating Brittany’s crib in a warm glow. A smile spread across my face; this was everything I had ever wished for.
Gazing at my baby girl, peacefully sleeping, I felt like the luckiest man alive. She was perfect—my little miracle.
For years, I had wondered if I would ever reach this point—married, a father, living in the house I had helped design. It had all felt so distant when I first met Nadine in college.
I still remember how she caught my eye, sitting on the steps outside the library with her sketchbook, lost in her work. From that moment, I knew she would be someone special in my life.
We fell in love quickly, and five years into our marriage, we welcomed Brittany. Our little angel had just turned four months old, and everything should have been perfect. Yet, I sensed something was off with Nadine.
She had grown distant, quieter than usual. I convinced myself it was the stress of new parenthood—sleepless nights and the pressures of her freelance work—but it began to take a toll on me.
I noticed her looking at Brittany with a strange expression, as if she bore the weight of the world. I didn’t know how to approach it, but today was meant to be a joyous occasion. It was Brittany’s baptism—a day to celebrate the life we had built.
I glanced toward the bedroom where Nadine was still asleep, curled under the blanket. Maybe today would lift her spirits; we both needed something to feel good about.
When we arrived at the church, everything felt right. The old stone walls and the smell of incense were familiar and comforting. This was the church where my parents were married and where I had been baptized. Now it was Brittany’s turn.
Nadine walked beside me, holding Brittany. She had been quiet all morning, her face pale. I assumed it was just nerves; big events always made her anxious.
“You okay?” I asked, gently squeezing her hand as we walked up the aisle.
“Yeah, just a little nervous,” she replied, forcing a tight smile.
I nodded, feeling reassured. Nerves—that’s all it was.
Father Gabriel welcomed us warmly, and the baptism began with prayers and blessings. A surge of pride filled me as I stood there with my family, believing this would be the moment I looked back on as the start of our perfect life together.
But then, Father Gabriel took Brittany into his arms, and something changed. The warmth in the room felt suddenly cold.
His hands trembled as he held her, and his expression shifted from gentle to confused. His eyes locked onto Brittany’s face, and he seemed shaken, as if he’d seen something that shouldn’t exist.
“What’s wrong?” I asked, a knot forming in my stomach.
Father Gabriel’s voice wavered as he looked at me, then back at Brittany. “This is impossible,” he whispered. “This child… she has my brother’s birthmark.”
My heart sank. “What did you just say?”
He swallowed hard, clearly grappling with the situation. “My brother, Matthew, and I both have a distinct crescent-shaped birthmark behind our left ears. It runs in our family. Brittany has the same mark.”
Continue reading on next page…